Our Pastor Just Resigned or Retired. What Now?
Whether it came after months of notice or out of nowhere, a pastor leaving puts a lot on the shoulders of elders, deacons and staff who already have full plates. Here is a simple order to take things in.
The first few weeks
- Cover the pulpit. Line up pulpit supply or an interim so Sundays are settled and nobody feels rushed.
- Check your bylaws. They usually say who forms the search team and who makes the final call.
- Name a search team. Five to seven people who represent the church and can keep a confidence is plenty.
- Agree on what you need. Settle the role, whether it is full time, and the compensation range before you advertise anything.
- Write it down. A clear job description and an honest picture of your church will save you months.
- Look wider than your own network. The right pastor is probably serving somewhere you have never heard of.
Where Lancaster Search comes in
You do not need a search committee in place to reach out. Elders, a board chair or an Executive Pastor can start the conversation, and we can help from the very beginning, bringing candidates from across the country to your team.
How it works for your church
- No contract. You are never locked in and can go a different direction at any point.
- You stay in control. Your search team does the interviews and makes the hiring decision.
- Active searching. We do not post an ad and wait. We go find candidates.
Who is behind Lancaster Search?
Dr. Jason Lancaster is a full-time Lead Pastor who has worked with pastors and churches for over 25 years. He started Lancaster Search in 2021 and has served more than 500 churches nationwide. He knows what a search looks like from the church’s side of the table.
Other searches we help with